With the 2011 baseball officially in the books, it is my pleasure to announce the second year of my project on the 50 best baseball players not in the Hall of Fame.
I debuted this project last year (here’s how it came out) with a simple goal. Rather than have my rankings based on some all-powerful stat or my opinion, I decided to go in a different direction and determine the picks through votes from other baseball writers, fans, and anyone interested. Sixty three people voted on about two week’s notice, including yours truly, and the project was a rousing success. Making it an annual thing here was an easy decision.
I have Super Ballot 2011 ready to send out to anyone who leaves a comment here or emails me at firstname.lastname@example.org. I invite anyone and everyone to vote, and I’ll link out in the results post to any baseball blogger who participates.
All this being said, please take a second to read the rules for this project. I can’t count any ballot that doesn’t adhere to them.
You must vote for 50 players: This was the biggest issue last year, so as we head into the second round of this project, let me reiterate. The point here isn’t to name 50 players who need to be enshrined in the Hall of Fame tomorrow or, conversely, to send in a 12-player ballot boldly proclaiming that only that many players belong. This project is about identifiying the 50 best players not in Cooperstown, whether they’re Hall-worthy or not. So please vote for 50 players. I will not count any final ballot with less (or more) than 50 players selected.
Please do not vote for anyone who’s played since the end of the 2006 season: We go with the same five-year waiting period that the Baseball Writers Association of America observes in its Hall of Fame voting each year. Other than that, any player in baseball history is fair game, with no restrictions on number of seasons played, whether the player is banned, or even if he made it to the majors.
Write-ins welcome: I’ve included nearly 400 players on this year’s ballot. That being said, roughly another 17,000 men have played in the majors and are not in the Hall of Fame. Please feel free to write in any player who hasn’t played in the last five years.
All votes due by December 1, 9 p.m. PST: No exceptions on this one. I will be rolling out the results after the Veterans Committee announces at the winter meetings in early December whether it will be enshrining anyone in 2012, and I need time to count votes and get the post ready.
I will not campaign for any player: I’d like for the results of this project to be as organic and independently-determined as possible. Thus, I will not advocate for any player being in the top 50. I also encourage anyone who votes to make their selections any way they please. Whether it’s relying on career stats, favoring peak value, looking toward members of particular eras, or going with some other method, it’s no worry to me how people vote. Definitions of what constituted a top 50 player varied among different voters last year, and I think it made for a more interesting final project.
New for this year’s project
“Does he belong in the HOF?” tab: Next to each of the 50 players selected, please put a Y or N (for “Yes” or “No”) signifying whether each player belongs in the Hall of Fame. I will list how this comes out in the results post.
Super Ballot 2011, bigger and better: Last year’s ballot featured 300 players, and some voters encouraged me to exclude players this year who’d gotten little or no votes. However, one voter quit in a huff last year because I neglected to include Vic Power, and I don’t want a repeat of that scene. Thus, this year’s ballot has close to 400 players. I brought back everyone from last year’s ballot, save for Roberto Alomar and Bert Blyleven who were enshrined this past summer. I also added in guys who last played in 2006, a few prominent omissions from last year’s ballot, every eligible write-in from last year, and every starter from a certain pennant winning team. I’ll give a free Baseball: Past and Present t-shirt to the first person who identifies the team.
Help me write about the players: I’d invite anyone interested to contribute 50 to 100 words on any player they vote for. I’ll select the best blurbs for inclusion with the post, with full credit for the respective writers, of course.
Anyhow, I look forward to seeing how this goes and thank everyone in advance who participates.
34 Replies to “Vote: The 50 best players not in the Hall of Fame, 2011 edition”
This was great last year. Look forward to doing it again!
This is great Graham. Did you time this to coincide with the opening night of the NBA season? If you didn’t, it is a nice move anyway. We need something to take our mind of the ridiculous state of basketball. Thanks for all your hard work!
YES! Been waiting all year for this.
Sounds like fun.
Can’t wait to vote and see the results!
I would love to take part in this again! I really enjoy seeing the results.
Lookin’ forward to doin’ this again
Looks like a lot of fun. Looking forward to it.
‘Count’ me in.
I woulkd like to participate. Long time blog reader but not much of a writer. Following MLB since 1964. Players of the 60’s and 70’s are IMHO, vastly underrepresented in the HOF. Start with Santo. Where do I go to put in my .02 worth?
I need a ballot! So I can vote for Dave Parker! And Pete Rose!
I would like a ballot. Sounds like a terrific idea and a lot of fun.
I’d like to participate. Thank you.
Count me in, please.
What a cool idea. I’m really looking forward to this.
I would love to participate, please.
I’m in. Please send a ballot. Thanks.
I’d like a ballot, please.
yes yes yes please send me a ballot thanks
I may have to include Victory Faust as a write-in!
@Gabriel So long as a guy hasn’t played in the majors since the end of the 2006 season and is not currently enshrined, you can vote for pretty much anyone.
I would love to participate. Thanks!
Excellent! I’m up for doing this again….
I would love to participate if I may.
I learned about this too late last year to participate, but would love to this year. Thanks!
Yes, this was a lot of fun and a great research exercise / discussion last year! This year looks to be even better… THANKS, Graham!
Ok, I’ll give this a shot. I’ll only submit if I come up with 50. Please send the ballot.
Sounds interesting. Please send me a ballot at your convenience. Thanks.
I’ve been pondering my ballot some and started looking over the ballot and I don’t know if your competition for which pennant winning team that has every starter has ended or not, but it looks to me that the 1989 SF Giants have every starter on the ballot.
Hi Bob, you are correct but another voter, Nick Diunte actually won this a few days ago. I may be able to offer you a discounted t-shirt!
Id love to get in on this
Cool idea, count us in.