Vote: The 50 best baseball players not in the Hall of Fame, Version 3.0

Hello everyone,

As some of you may know, I do an annual project having people rank the 50 best baseball players not in the Hall of Fame. It’s that time again.

I invite anyone who’s interested to take part (please free also to pass ballots along to anyone interested.) To vote, click on this link which will take you a Google Form that’s accepting responses. I’ve also included a reference ballot with about 430 names.

I don’t have too many rules for this project, but here they are:

1. You must vote for 50 players. Next to each player you vote for, include a Y or N for if they belong in the Hall of Fame
2. Any player who’s been inactive at least five years is eligible, whether they’ve played in the majors or not
3. All votes are due by next Sunday December 9 at 9 p.m. PST. I’ll post the results on December 16
Beyond this, please feel free to email me at with any questions.
Anyhow, I look forward to seeing how you all vote!
Best wishes,
Graham Womack

9 Replies to “Vote: The 50 best baseball players not in the Hall of Fame, Version 3.0”

  1. Graham! Glad to see you back and writing! It’s been too long.

    Also, glad to see the project’s back up and running. Submitted my ballot already, and hope I didn’t make any mistakes. Can’t wait to see the results in year three!

  2. Another great crowdsourcing project. I hope you get a lot of participation. So many great choices and not enough room on the ballot. I can’t wait to see the results.

  3. Hi,I have a suggestion,how about 50 or so guys ,that dont belong in the Hall of Fame.Its so watered down already,ie,The Scooter

  4. Bucky Walters Y
    Wilber Wood Y
    S.J. Wood Y
    J. Torre Y
    Riggs Stephenson Y
    LeeSmith Y
    Curt Schilling Y
    Tip O’Neil Y
    Denny McLain Y
    Ted Kluzewski Y
    Jim Kaat Y
    Wally Berger Y
    Ned Garver Y
    Jose Canseco Y
    Barry Bonds N
    Bobby Bonds N
    E. Cicotte N
    J. Jackson N
    R. Clemons N
    D. Graves N
    D. Kingman N
    G. Luzinski N
    C. Maldonado N
    M. Matheny N
    P. Rose N
    S. Sosa N
    M. McGwire N
    V. Power N
    J. Randa N
    J. Rudi N
    G. Tenace N
    F. Walker N
    l. Whitaker N
    E. Young N
    S. Bando N
    D. Baker N
    J. Adcock N
    K. Appier N
    D. Bartell N
    L. Bostock N
    L. Bowa NM
    E. Burks N
    H. Chase N
    L. Easter N
    F. Fain N
    J. Fournier N
    G. Fostyer N
    B. Freehan N
    B. Friend N

  5. Glad to see you back on track with Baseball Past & Present, Graham!

    Submitted my ballot the other day, though I wish I took more time to contemplate the non-obvious candidates.

  6. There is probably nothing more controversial than who gets in and who does not. The debate always revolves around those at the margins.

    Myles Raucher

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *